Trigger Points – What do we Know?

2021-03-04T13:39:00+00:00March 3rd, 2021|

Many sports and clinical massage therapists, including myself, will use Trigger Point therapy as part of their toolbox – but what exactly are they and does pressing them really help to relieve pain? For this article I’m going to look at some of the differing opinions amongst researchers on Trigger Points. Most people agree that there is some sort of phenomenon going on here involving painful spots within muscle tissue. However, the research on Trigger Points is far from definitive and we certainly are not at a point where we can say that we ‘know’ what the story is.

What are Trigger Points anyway?

The Trigger Point phenomenon was described by Janet Travell and David Simons in their 1998 book ‘Myofascial Pain and Dysfunction: The Trigger Point Manual (1). They define them as:

 “…a hyperirritable spot in skeletal muscle that is associated with a hypersensitive palpable nodule in a taut band. The spot is tender when pressed, and can give rise to characteristic referred pain, motor dysfunction, and autonomic phenomena.” 

Which basically means they are sore spots in your muscles that are painful when you press on them. Trigger Points are also said to refer pain to other areas of the body in predictable ways. For example, Trigger Points in the Trapezius muscle, the large muscle that covers your shoulders and much of your upper back, may refer pain up into the sides of your head and temples. They also describe various ways that you might get them, including muscular overexertion, stress and awkward postures.

Travell and Simons’ Trigger Point theory also encompasses the existence of ‘latent Trigger Points’ – Trigger Points that exist in muscles without causing pain, unless pressed, but which can be activated by a variety of triggers. And ‘satellite Trigger Points’ – ones that arise in the zone of referred pain caused by the ‘primary Trigger Point’.

So, what does the science say?

The ‘Integrated Hypothesis’ of Myofascial Trigger Points (MTPs), presented in updated form by Simons in 2006 (2), suggests that dysfunction in release or uptake of neurotransmitters at the motor end plate (the junction between a motor nerve and a muscle cell) triggers a whole series of physiological processes that effectively results in a tiny muscle spasm. These tiny muscle spasms can compress capillaries, starving the area of oxygen and resulting in a ‘local energy crisis’.

Some resulting chemicals can activate nociceptors – the nerve fibres that send danger signals to the brain which may then be translated into the sensation of pain. Over the long term, continued activation of nociceptors causes changes in the central nervous system that makes it more efficient in producing pain sensations.

Controversy in the Trigger Point world

Although Simons’ ‘Integrated Hypothesis’ seems to have been widely accepted, almost as fact by many therapists, we need to remember that it is actually still just a hypothesis with a few pieces of supporting evidence. The hypothesis is also incomplete and controversial, inspiring some strong disagreement amongst scientists.

The main source of disagreement comes from Dr. John Quintner, a specialist in chronic pain, who completely refutes the Integrated Hypothesis. He suggests instead that Trigger Points are not some ‘thing’ to be found in muscle tissue but could be due to inflammation of peripheral nerves (3). However, there is not really any convincing evidence for this theory either (4). Other scientists have since taken the Integrated Hypothesis and further developed it in an attempt to fill in some of the gaps (6).

I don’t care about the science – does it work??

Paul Ingraham is a former massage therapist and sceptic who has investigated Trigger Point research in great detail. His Trigger Point ebook has a huge amount of information. If you have nerd level interest – in what they are and what to do about them – then I recommend you purchase his book. He goes through all the debates on what a Trigger Point is, as well as looking at the science that exists on how well massage therapy works to treat them. He lists several studies, but on the whole it’s difficult to take a hard and fast conclusion from it. Most of the studies he describes are of low quality and have a high risk of bias. Where some do show positive effects, they are small to moderate.

What does this mean in practice?

In effect, Trigger Point therapy, as Ingraham points out, can be viewed more accurately as an experimental method. It’s not a ‘proven approach’. Most therapists will have many stories of sometimes miraculous effects from Trigger Point therapy, but this does not constitute ‘evidence’. It’s possible that Trigger Points have something to do with your pain. It’s also possible that treating them either yourself or with the help of a therapist can help. As long as we are clear that we’re doing a bit of an experiment.

Can I do it myself?

Yes! Again, I recommend Paul Ingraham’s (long) tutorial on Trigger Points linked to earlier. He also sells several in depth ebooks on different subjects such as back pain, headaches or plantar fasciitis for example. In most cases a tennis ball is a great tool, but other kinds of balls or foam rollers can work better for different areas.

Trigger Points are not always found where it hurts, so some guidance as to where to look might be needed. For example, pain in the lower back may arise from Trigger Points in the Quadratus Lumborum (a small muscle underneath the spinal erectors that attaches to the 12th rib, the lumbar spine and the top of the pelvis) or in the Gluteus Medius on the side of the hip. Or referred pain in the arm that may come from Trigger Points in the neck, in the scalene muscles.

I’m also always happy to help clients with ways they can do this kind of work themselves at home. Be prepared to dedicate some time to it and experiment!

In summary

We can probably agree that there are sore spots in muscles that are painful when you press on them and can give rise to the sensation of pain referred to other areas. We don’t know for sure what they actually are, but we have a working hypothesis, although not everyone agrees with it. Many therapists and clients have the experience of relieving pain through working with trigger points, although we cannot say that there is good scientific evidence of the efficacy of Trigger Point therapy.

I do offer Trigger Point therapy and will continue to do so, unless the evidence convinces me that otherwise.  In some cases, it seems to be extremely helpful, although not in everyone. Sometimes I am sure there must be a trigger point here somewhere and yet I can’t find it. Sometimes I find them, but the pain persists. Sometimes it’s extremely clear – the Trigger Point exists just where I expect it to be and recreates my client’s pain exactly, and treating it is followed by a welcome relief. It is not an exact science – we have established that. However, what I can say is that it seems to me that a certain amount of pain could very well be down to the activity of trigger points, and it could well be worth exploring.

References:

(1) Travell, J. & Simons, D., 1998. Myofascial Pain and Dysfunction: They Trigger Point Manual, Lipincott Williams and Williams.

(2) McPartland, J. & Simons, D., 2006. Myofascial Trigger Points: Translating Molecular Theory into Manual Therapy. J Manual & Manipulative Therapy 14(4):232–239.

(3) Quintner, J.L., Bove, G.M. & Cohen, M.L., 2014. A critical evaluation of the trigger point phenomenon. Rheumatology (Oxford) June 54(6):1127-8

(4) Dommerholt, J. & Gerwin, R. 2015. A Critical Evaluation of Quintner et al: Missing the Point. J Bodywork & Movement Therapies 19(2):193-204.

(5) Jafri, M.S., 2014. Mechanisms of Myofascial Pain. International Scholarly Research Notices, 1-16.